Round Knight Rating

Voulge Knight: Great - Technically, this guy came after the deadline, but, more technically, he was a perfect fit.

Sceptre Knight: Okay - What can I say that the game didn't?

Icicle Knight: Okay - Everyone knows that the real freezing weapon is a Sickle! -Ometon

Pitchfork Knight: Poor - Despite being similar to a trident, I felt like letting this one through.

Chain Knight: Okay - I guess I'm a sucker for chains. Fun fact: it's Mace Knight's fake name!

Steed Knight: Great - It's a fun concept... although the knights tend to just run or BAMF on screen.

Skewer: Great - It's good, but the Dream Land 2 Knights were the aimed model, just a furthered examples.

Hook Knight: Fair - This goes out directly to Kiroscarby: Seriously, another tall knight burdened with details? Not taking any hints, are we?

Lightning Knight: Fair - "Explosive" falls short of this guy. A bit over.

Razor Knight: Okay - When I first saw Razor, I thought, "Great! An aqua knight." As I read, I started saying, "Okay..." I left off with, "... Poison?"

Spike Knight: Okay - Spike gets half way there, but leaves a lot open and untold.

Fan Knight: Okay - The dude's a little too naked for my knight tastes.

Bow Knight: Okay - All the attention to detail is nice an' all, but it kinda goes overboard and distracts from the underlying point -- the knight.

Dagger Knight: Okay - Wait, it's brown and teal? That trip-up alone has me out.

Lance Knight: Great - Wields a weapon. Simple shape. Routine attack pattern. Thank you! Is this so hard to do?

Feather Knight: Great - It comes across more like a Wing giving enemy than a Meta Knight.

Laser Knight: Okay - How come some Knights are the weapon rather than using weapons?

Shell Knight: Fair - Sometimes, the "elemental" affects seem tacked on, but this one goes for broke with all them. (Was requested to be removed, but my judgement remains)

Tonfa Knight: Great - Cut and clean. If only some more was said about his finer details in appearance.

Crossbow Knight: Okay - It's kinda funny that nothing is really said about what it exactly does. Sure, an idea is given, shootin' and stabbin', but it's more of vaguely inferred.

Darkness Knight: Fair - Why is it the more I say, "These aren't mini-bosses. Stop making them mini-bosses. Make them like normal enemies," people appear to do the opposite?

Ripsaw Knight: Okay - This guy nicely reminds me of Javelin's dervish attack style but then goes and ruins it by trying to be "too tough".

Wood Knight: Great - While the "listening" is an innovative idea, it begs the question whether such extrordinary behavior is suiting to this level of enemy.

Knuckles Knight: Great - It's good, and how couldn't it be? It has alliteration!

Parasol Knight: Superb - This guy is perfect. I couldn't imagine a soldier more fit to wield an umbrella.

Club Knight: Okay - There's a such thing as too much information, and this guy goes overboard with the details, most of which have no meaning.

Blunderbuss Knight: Okay - It started off good but then got way too complicated for what should be a regular enemy.

Shock Knight: Great - I like how the creator noted that the tazer was an unusually weapon, but the design is spot-on.

Thorn Knight: Okay - And now that the name is changed from "Needle" Knight, I got nothing.

Whip Knight (2): Superb - Wonderful. His appearance was easily understood, and fully, and his behavior is exactly like what a Knight should be.

Disk Knight: Great - He wields a nice, original weapon and has a competent and cultured design.

Glide Knight: Great - Don't know why, but this guy looks like he's a Koopa Troopa.

Ring Knight: Okay - "I like Whip Knight's design, but I wish he had lame, clichanimé hair. Hmm..."

Bomb Knight (2): Okay - The pack mentality came across as strange since the knights almost always work with other knights.

Crossbow Knight: Okay - Arrows freeze why? Oh, sometimes. That makes perfect sense.

Sai Knight: Fair - It's a well rounded ninja... too bad this is a contest for knights.

Boomerang Knight (2): Okay - Of the many attempts this submitter made, this broke zero rules... barely.

Boomerang Knight: Okay - Hey, wait, it's behavior is exactly what it should be. Shock!

Cane Knight: Okay - Why can't anyone just be killed as per a normal enemy? You know, like all the other knights?

Bomb Knight: Okay - Remember kids, "one or two actions" means "four or more", apparently.

Whip Knight: Great - It's like a Snooter mixed with a mini-boss, and I still don't see how either fits in here.

Mage Knight: Great - The concept, while interesting, is a bit over the top and misses the point and spirit of the contest.

Spade Knight: Okay - Makin' stars? What does this guy think he is? A mini-boss?

Hammer Knight: Great - Just a reminder that they can just have a real weapon and not be 'bots. Also, how large should be made since that seems to be all that is.

Slash Knight: Great - Why can't he be named after his weapon? I mean, really. "Slash"?

Nunchaku Knight: Okay - Sure, Ax Knight does it, but axes at least have a history of being thrown.

Cannon Knight: Okay - Honestly, it's like the submitter read Mortar Knight and said "I can do less."

Drill Knight: Okay - There's a flame on his head why?.

Blaster Knight: Okay - Good. Better. Great. Light Saber?!? You lost me. Also, why so many acts?

Scythe Knight (2): Great - I liked it. It wasn't just, "Woo, I'm da reaper." The deathly chill was a nice adaptation.

Scythe Knight: Great - I bit extravagent, but I can see it being in a game.

Mortar Knight: Great - Shouldn't it be "Cannon Knight" instead of Mortar?

Grappling Hook Knight: Great - I got lost somewhere in there.

Torch Knight: Great - My Torch Knight was a flying furnace.

Jet Knight: Fair - Is this a Capsule J3 or just Kirby with Jet?

Dual Knight: Great - I didn't want to use this one as a sample, but I also didn't want to use up any other more common name.

Shield Knight: Great - It was my own. I can't say much on it.